Neo-conservatives decided that World War III is to be waged against
“Islamic-Fascists” or “Islamo-Fascism.”
Who is reading from the new script? William Kristol, Bill O’Reilly,
Christopher Hitchens, Michelle Mankin, Michael Savage, Ann Coulter, Nick Cohen,
Newt Gingrich, Rush Limbaugh, Daniel Pipes, Glenn Beck, Oliver North –
even George W. Bush, prompting legitimate complaints from Muslim-Americans.
Middle Eastern powers include pan-Arab socialist dictatorships (Syria),
monarchies (Saudi Arabia), constitutional theocracies (Iran), and assorted fundamentalist
movements. None are “fascist.” For three decades of political scientists,
“fascism” is a phenomenon of industrialized societies and exhibits
features alien to the Middle East.
Classical fascism was evident in inter-war Italy, Germany and Japan, and full-blown
fascism exhibits three dimensions: economic, political and cultural.
1. Economic fascism is based a merger of big business and
big government. Sometimes, a formal corporatism emerges; other times, the private
sector (monopolies and oligopolies) simply pass over into the public sector
(as in the US), capturing the state and using it to wage that most profitable
of activities: war. This later scenario is what happened in the United States,
and the incestuous relationship between Big Business and Big Government ushered
in a new Gilded Age of cronyism and corruption. Benito Mussolini was clear:
“Fascism should more appropriately be called Corporatism because it is
a merger of State and corporate power.”
For the Middle East, the preconditions of mature capitalism (and thus fascism)
simply do not exist.
2. Political fascism normally includes, as it did for Italy
and Germany, a retreat from already-existing democratic practices – an
erosion of democracy. The political class begins to express a disdain for human
rights and international treaties, lashing out at pillars of civilization like
France. Power is increasingly centered on the executive branch, and elections
become less transparent, even fraudulent. Civil liberties are restricted, and
constitutions are ground under the hobnailed boot.
Political fascism always depicts dissent as treason, and there is an obsession
with scapegoats and plots. There are frequent mixed messages about the enemy:
the enemy is strong, then weak; the enemy is important; then irrelevant. Today,
the Party depicts Hezbollah as having unlimited funds from Iran and, simultaneously,
selling pirated DVDs and fake Viagra in your town.
Political fascism is based on militant nationalism, pseudo-populism and an
adoration of military power. As Huey Long said, former Governor of Louisiana:
“When fascism comes to America, it will be wrapped in the American flag.”
For different reasons, these values tend to resonate among economic elites at
the top and the lower middle class at the bottom. In the United States, however,
it appears that the lower and working classes are now questioning their leadership
– or losing themselves in End of Empire entertainment: pan y circo (bread
In its advanced stages, political fascism depends upon mass surveillance and,
more crucially, eternal war. Italy’s mad adventures in Ethiopia and Germany’s
insane and unwinnable two-front war were nursed by the ideology of eternal war.
The only ingredient of classical political fascism missing in the United States
is a charismatic leader – but not for lack of trying. In Red States, billboards
of George W. “Our Leader” arose, and fundamentalists synchronized
Morning Prayer to those of the White House.
Middle East powers – particularly the movements neo-cons describe as
“Islamofascist” – are emerging in non-democratic systems.
They are also pushing for more, not less, political democracy because the popular
classes will catapult them to power and keep them there.
Hamas, for example, won in an election. Egypt’s Muslim Brotherhood would
very much like to go to the polls in more transparent elections. Shia Muslims
in Iraq are also keen on voting. Iran’s president won an election handily.
And when the dust settles in Lebanon, the next sure winner at the ballot box
will be Hezbollah, when Lebanese Christians, Sunnis and Druze will surely wait
in lines for hours to endorse this radical Shia group. Democracy, it seems,
is about to flourish in the Middle East – it’s just not yielding
the puppet regimes hoped for in Washington, London (Airstrip One) or Tel Aviv.
Tony Snow claims “they hate democracy.” Don’t be snowed.
Islamic fundamentalist groups compete at the national level, but Islamic fundamentalism
is a transnational movement inherently opposed to the pseudo-nationalism necessary
3. Cultural fascism is based on a reaction against science,
modernity, the arts and intellectualism. It distorts science to accomplish political
aims. Cultural fascism always includes strong doses of homophobia.
In the US, for every person with legitimate objections to immigration (objections
based on public policy), there must be three people objecting to it based on
race, and for them “illegal” becomes a euphemism for “Mexican.”
Xenophobia is basic to cultural fascism.
Cultural fascism, in the West, tends towards anti-Semitism. For now, American
anti-Semitism has an anti-Arab face. In linguistics and ethnology, the term
“Semitic” includes “Arabic” and “Arabs.”
A Marriam-Webster definition of “Semite” is clear: “A member
of any of a number of peoples of ancient southwestern Asia including the Akkadians,
Phoenicians, Hebrews, and Arabs.”
Thus, when neo-con pundits, politicians and even the President employ the term
“Islamo-Fascist” they are being anti-Semitic.
Middle Eastern and Islamic movements can be reactionary, but these are reactions
to external powers and not to the core dimensions of their own societies, which
So the economic, political and cultural prerequisites of fascism do
not exist in the Middle East – but they do exist in the United States.
Our post-WWII, Information Age neo-fascism is much like the inter-war classical
fascism but softer, lighter, friendlier. Today, instead of marching, we ritually
demonstrate our political will on touch-screen pads, a ceremony organized by
Party-backed corporations with secret software on private servers.
It’s a race: Will the future look like Aldous Huxley’s Brave New
World, where a “dictatorship without tears” is founded upon psychotropic
drugs, false religion and biological-sexual engineering? Or will it be a world
of brute force like George Orwell’s 1984? “If you want a vision
of the future, imagine a boot stamping on a human face - forever.” It
will be both: A Brave New World for those who conform and 1984 for those who
don’t. American fascism will both smile and grimace.
Neo-con pundits follow a clever strategy of deflection. They employ the term
“Islamo-Fascism” when “theocracy” or “dictatorship”
or “fundamentalist movement” would be more historically accurate.
Why do they do this? Their political epithets are inspired by a subtle conditioning
Perhaps it’s subconscious projection. “Projection,” of course,
is a defense mechanism that kicks when someone is threatened by, or afraid of,
their own impulse. So they attribute these impulses to someone else. Do not
be neo-conned. How can you help?
First, always replace the term “neo-conservatism”
Second, always charge those who use the term “Islamo-fascism”
with anti-Semitism (because Arabs – most of whom are Muslims – are
technically “Semitic,” too).
Third, remind people who use the term “Islamo-Fascism”
that the term is historically inaccurate and that the main ingredients of classical
fascism – 1) monopoly capitalism; 2) erosion of democracy; and 3) militant
nationalism – are coming together in the United States like a Perfect
It’s not fair to perform a vivisection of the Bush regime without pointing
to what a healthier body politic might look like – a “post-crisis”
1) The restoration of the checks and balances, and limited
government, of a democratic republic. This includes voter protections and a
pencil-paper-box voting system.
2) The restoration of foreign relations to open diplomacy
(as envisioned by the Founders) – to the power of persuasion - unless
attacked, upon which military force will be restricted to the forces demonstrably
responsible. This means no foreign aid, no weapons sales, no forward bases,
and no committing political adultery by dividing loyalties between the people
of the United States and any foreign power. The American people can express
their solidarity with people around the world with short-term disaster relief.
3) Challenging both Israel and Arab powers to follow the letter
of international law. Compliance means full participation in an international
economy and community (the carrot); and resistance invites the atrophy of embargoes,
travel restrictions, and blockages (the stick). Under UN Resolution 181, Israel
secures its right to exist according to the 1948 borders, with protection from
the United Nations. Simultaneously, Israel withdraws all of its settler colonies
from the West Bank, illegal under Article 49 of the Geneva Conventions: “The
Occupying Power shall not deport or transfer parts of its own civilian population
into the territory it occupies.” And Jerusalem becomes the international
city as intended in 1948.
4) Challenging the world’s people and states with a
transformative proposal: universal nuclear disarmament. If states do not disarm,
take the proposal to their peoples. Inspired, motivated and determined, masses
of people will quickly sideline both foot-dragging politicians and terrorists.
The best weapon against terror is not the US Army; it is civilized men and women
everywhere. The world is ready to make nuclear weapons - and then war - extinct.
Thomas Paine: “We have it in our power to make the world new again.”
Andrew Bosworth teaches Political Science and is author
of an upcoming book. American
Apocalypse? How to Reverse Tyranny and Empire.
Read from Looking Glass News
Characteristics Of Fascism And America's Development As A Fascist Nation
then. Fascism now?
to tell if you are in a tyrannical police state
Ten Signs of the Impending U.S. Police State
in America: Are We There Yet?
of Creeping Fascism
please': I smell the long-forgotten rot of fascism'