press release as an Adobe PDF document.
The latest audio tape attributed to Osama bin Laden appears to be one
more installment in a succession of evidence fabricated by the US government
to deceive the American people, according to Scholars for 9/11 Truth. "This
tape is only the latest in a series of fabrications intended to mislead the
American people," said James H. Fetzer, the society's founder. "The
closer we get to revealing he truth about 9/11, the more furiously the government
fights to conceal it!" He said members of Scholars and other experts had
detected evidence of fakery.
In this new recording, a voice attributed to Osama bin Laden asserts that Zacarias
Moussaoui was not involved in 9/11, which he knew to be the case because he
had personally assigned the 19 hijackers involved in those events. The Osama
of this tape thereby implicitly confesses his responsibility for orchestrating
the attacks. However, in a tape released on December 27, 2001, the authenticity
of which is not in doubt, Osama denied having had anything to do with 9/11.
"Moreover," Fetzer added, "some of the 19 hijackers he 'personally
assigned' have turned up alive and well."
To be sure, this new tape is not the first one in which bin Laden appears to
take responsibility for the attacks. As David Ray Griffin, a prominent member
of Scholars, points out, "The Osama on the video tape that appeared on
December 13, 2001, confessed to planning the 9/11 attacks. But he is far darker
and much heavier than the real Osama bin Laden. People can see the difference
by looking up 'The Fake bin Laden Video Tape' on google."
Griffin's point is supported by a work-in-progress by members of Scholars for
9/11 Truth, which appears on its web site under the heading, "9/11: Have
we been lied to?" It offers evidence of fakery in some of the videos based
upon various physical properties of the figures that are presumed to be Osama,
pointing out that there are differences in the ears, cheeks, eyebrows, length
of the nose and shape of the nostrils. "The use of computer analysis can
'fine tune' these questions of facial characteristics," Fetzer said, "but
the gross differences already show they are not the same."
"Another problem with the video of December 13, 2001," Griffin pointed
out, "was that its stocky bin Laden praised two of the alleged hijackers,
Wail M. Al-Shehri and Salem al-Hazmi, by name, and yet both the London Telegraph
and the Saudi embassy reported several days after 9/11 that al-Hazmi was still
alive and working in Saudi Arabia. Given the fact that the earlier video in
which Osama confessed was clearly a fake, we should be suspicious of this latest
A professor at Duke, Bruce Lawrence, who has published Messages to the World:
The Statements of Osama bin Laden, expressed profound skepticism about a tape
that was released January 17, 2006, in a report that appeared two days later.
"There's nothing in this from the Koran," Lawrence said. "He's,
by his own standards, a faithful Muslim who quotes scripture in defense of his
actions. There's no quotation from the Koran in the excerpts we got, no reference
to specific events, no reference to past atrocities." Lawrence also observed
the tape ran only 10 minutes, whereas the shortest previous tape, at 18 minutes,
was nearly twice as long.
Fetzer noted that many of the same anomalous properties are found in the latest
tape. "Compared to Osama's past performances," he observed, "this
message is too short, too direct, and full of falsehoods. It was even described
on CBS News by Bob Schieffer as 'almost American'." A translation of the
text of the tape has also been released by IntelCenter, a private company that
does contract work for the US government. "I suppose I would be accused
of being a 'conspiracy theorist' to suggest there is any connection," Fetzer
Authentic Voice/Fake Content
Informed that Reuters news agency has reported confirmation that the voice
on the tape is indeed that of Osama bin Laden, Fetzer replied, "The fact
that the voice is his does not prove that the tape is authentic. We have had
phony tapes before using voices that were authentic. Mark Bingham, a passenger
on Flight 93, is supposed to have called his mother and said, 'Hi, Mom, this
is Mark Bingham!' His mother confirmed it was his voice, but does anyone seriously
believe that Mark Bingham would have used his last name in identifying himself
to his mother?"
Griffin agreed, adding, "Back in 1999, William Arkin published an article
entitled, 'When Seeing and Hearing isn't Believing' (which can also be accessed
on google). Describing the new technology of 'voice morphing' (or 'voice synthesizing'),
Arkin explained that, if audio technicians have a recording of your voice, then
they can create a tape in which your voiceï¿½your authentic
voice!ï¿½says anything they wish."
In a press release on April 22, 2006, the Scholars observed that a tape played
at the trail of Zacarias Moussaoui included discussion among the passengers
about using a drink cart to break down the cabin door alleged to have been picked
up on a cockpit voice recorder, which does not record conversations in the passenger
cabin. "This is not the first and certainly will not be the last time that
the American government plays the American people for suckers," Fetzer
"We have just acquired new evidence that the Pentagon video tapes were
processed and manipulated in an apparent effort to distort or conceal what happened
there on 9/11," Fetzer observed. "Apparently, whenever the government
feels the need to bolster the official myth about 9/11, it simply fabricates
a new tape! Anybody who wants to keep score should visit our web site."
Scholars for 9/11 Truth is a non-partisan society of experts
and scholars dedicated to exposing falsehoods and establishing truths about
the events of 9/11. It maintains a web site at st911.org, where it archives
its studies, documents, records and evidence.