Untitled Document
"I am appalled that our government has mocked our Constitutional
values and toddled into a corridor of totalitarian techniques that gruesomely
mortifies the face of America into a Socialist Superstate. Since the horrible
murder of common sense, the satanic goddess of Reason and Liberty has stepped
in for a one-two punch against our fourth Amendment rights; and none dare
call it treason" - Louis Turner
For years, governments all over the world have secretly been collaborating
with the high-end color laser printer industry in order to track the origin
of every color copy made.
They're doing it by programming the printers to create specific patterns
of yellow dots - not visible to the naked eye - on every copy. These dot patterns
are codes for the serial number, the make of the printer, and possibly even
the time and date when the print was made. By cross-checking this information
with printer company databases of people who have purchased the printers, federal
agents can figure out who made a given color copy (of, say, an antiwar rally
flyer) and when.
No, really.
Xerox has openly admitted it shares its customer lists with the US
Secret Service if asked. And both the US Secret Service and the Dutch
government told PC World in a recent article that they asked printer companies
to create the yellow dot patterns to help law enforcement track down counterfeiting
suspects. Because color laser copies are so good, counterfeiters frequently
use them to create fake money, as well as fake train tickets and other valuable
items.
Right now, the system works because most people don't know about it, and you
can only see the yellow dots if you look at the paper under a blue light (to
highlight the yellow). Generally you need a magnifying glass or a weak microscope
too. It also works because color laser printers are high-end enough that most
people buy them using credit cards. That's how the laser printer companies generate
their lists of purchasers associated with specific printer serial numbers.
Robert Lee, a computer science student, spent the summer after graduating from
Yale researching these yellow printer dots, trying to figure out which companies
were using them and what they might mean. My coworkers at the Electronic Frontier
Foundation (EFF) helped him along, giving legal and technical pointers along
the way. The result of two months spent peering at color laser copies with a
blue LED was the discovery that only one model in his study doesn't use the
yellow dots: the Xerox TekTronix Phaser 7700. But most other Xerox models do,
as do all the ones he tested by Canon and Toshiba.
Because so little is known about what the yellow dots mean (aside from containing
the make and serial number) and how governments are using them, many disturbing
questions arise. For example, how do we know they're only using these printer
marks to track counterfeiters? What if they're also tracking people who copy
what they think are anonymous political flyers or pamphlets? Or people who post
flyers announcing meetings of Muslim groups?
One of the fundamental ways the First Amendment works is by protecting anonymous
free speech. These dots undermine your ability to make a color copy anonymously.
The government can most likely track the document back to you. Even if you pay
cash for color printouts at Kinko's, your purchase or visit to the store will
probably be recorded by a security camera. It appears that the dots may contain
a time stamp, so it would be relatively easy to cross-reference video of a 5:15
p.m. purchase with some copies made at 5:12.
How can this happen? Shouldn't there be a law? Yes, there should be, but as
of now there are absolutely no regulations or laws that stop printer companies
or copy shops from giving information about their customers to the government.
Phone companies and Internet service providers, by contrast, are forbidden to
give the government data about you unless served with a court order. But this
isn't true for credit card records kept by laser printer companies. Sure, these
companies could demand court orders, but none of them have. Xerox told Lee that
it has always been happy to comply with the government when asked for this kind
of data.
But there is something you can do about it, besides writing angry letters to
your local congresscritter. Seth Schoen of the EFF is continuing Lee's work,
gathering as many color copies as he can (see
EFF's page on copiers), and he's received 200 responses so far, from all
over the world. He's analyzing the patterns of dots, trying to crack the code
to figure out what they say. Most of all, he and Lee want the public to know
what they're getting when they print color copies.
Each time you create something on a color laser printer, you're sending a little
message to the government: Here's who I am, and here's how to find me.
Annalee Newitz is
a surly media nerd who prefers blue dots.
Government Uses Color Laser Printer Technology to Track Documents
Practice Embeds Hidden, Traceable Data in Every Page Printed
By: Jason Tuohey - Medill News Service
WASHINGTON - Next time you make a printout from your color laser printer, shine
an LED flashlight beam on it and examine it closely with a magnifying glass.
You might be able to see the small, scattered yellow dots printed there that
could be used to trace the document back to you.
According to experts, several printer companies quietly encode the serial number
and the manufacturing code of their color laser printers and color copiers on
every document those machines produce. Governments, including the United States,
already use the hidden markings to track counterfeiters.
Peter Crean, a senior research fellow at Xerox,
says his company's laser printers, copiers and multifunction workstations, such
as its WorkCentre Pro series, put the "serial number of each machine coded
in little yellow dots" in every printout. The millimeter-sized dots appear
about every inch on a page, nestled within the printed words and margins.
"It's a trail back to you, like a license plate," Crean says.
The dots' minuscule size, covering less than one-thousandth of the page, along
with their color combination of yellow on white, makes them invisible to the
naked eye, Crean says. One way to determine if your color laser is applying
this tracking process is to shine a blue LED light--say, from a keychain laser
flashlight--on your page and use a magnifier.
Crime Fighting vs. Privacy
Laser-printing technology makes it incredibly easy to counterfeit money and
documents, and Crean says the dots, in use in some printers for decades, allow
law enforcement to identify and track down counterfeiters.
However, they could also be employed to track a document back to any person
or business that printed it. Although the technology has existed for a long
time, printer companies have not been required to notify customers of the feature.
Lorelei Pagano, a counterfeiting specialist with the U.S. Secret Service, stresses
that the government uses the embedded serial numbers only when alerted to a
forgery. "The only time any information is gained from these documents
is purely in [the case of] a criminal act," she says.
John Morris, a lawyer for The Center for Democracy
and Technology, says, "That type of assurance doesn't really assure
me at all, unless there's some type of statute." He adds, "At a bare
minimum, there needs to be a notice to consumers."
If the practice disturbs you, don't bother trying to disable the encoding mechanism--you'll
probably just break your printer.
Crean describes the device as a chip located "way in the machine, right
near the laser" that embeds the dots when the document "is about 20
billionths of a second" from printing.
"Standard mischief won't get you around it," Crean adds.
Neither Crean nor Pagano has an estimate of how many laser printers, copiers,
and multifunction devices track documents, but they say that the practice is
commonplace among major printer companies.
"The industry absolutely has been extraordinarily helpful [to law enforcement],"
Pagano says.
According to Pagano, counterfeiting cases are brought to the Secret Service,
which checks the documents, determines the brand and serial number of the printer,
and contacts the company. Some, like Xerox, have a customer database, and they
share the information with the government.
Crean says Xerox and the government have a good relationship. "The U.S.
government had been on board all along--they would actually come out to our
labs," Crean says.
History
Unlike ink jet printers, laser
printers, fax machines, and copiers fire a laser through a mirror and series
of lenses to embed the document or image on a page. Such devices range from
a little over $100 to more than $1000, and are designed for both home and office.
Crean says Xerox pioneered this technology about 20 years ago, to assuage fears
that their color copiers could easily be used to counterfeit bills.
"We developed the first (encoding mechanism) in house because several
countries had expressed concern about allowing us to sell the printers in their
country," Crean says.
Since then, he says, many other companies have adopted the practice.
The United States is not the only country teaming with private industry to
fight counterfeiters. A recent
article points to the Dutch government as using similar anticounterfeiting
methods, and cites Canon as a company with encoding technology. Canon USA declined
to comment.
FAIR USE NOTICE: This site contains copyrighted material the use of which has
not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making
such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of environmental,
political, human rights, economic, democracy, scientific, and social justice
issues, etc. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted
material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance
with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without
profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included
information for research and educational purposes. For more information go to:
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml.
Related Links:
Source 1: Alternet.org
Source 2: PC
World